52 Responses to “Top Fifty Movies Of 2000-09”

  1. Megan Mullins says:

    Fantastic list! I would have changed the order on a few of them. Sometimes you forget about movies so now I want to watch movies all day.

    Reply
  2. Castor says:

    Absolutely love your list. It’s amazing how similar it is to the top 100 I’m currently working on. Only disappointed not to see Mulholland Dr. up there but I agree with the vast majority of it. It’s also nice to see movies like American Psycho, or The Last Samurai which don’t figure prominently on most top films of the decade list.

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      I haven’t seen Mulholland Dr. It’s nothing personal! It’s actually in my 100 movies to see in 2010 list!

      Glad to see the appreciation for some of the movies I love but don’t get enough attention!

      Reply
    • Heather says:

      And……….I can’t wait to read your Top 100. Great minds and all.

      Reply
      • Castor says:

        Merry Christmas by the way ;)

        Reply
        • Heather says:

          Thank you, I hope you had a Merry Christmas as well.

          Reply
  3. George says:

    great list….I don’t know how you do it!!

    Reply
    • Maude says:

      George they watch movies and then write a list. you should write your fave’s.

      Reply
  4. Andy says:

    Great list, a lot of thought must have gone into a top 50, I have enough trouble with top tens. I love 85% of the movies on the list so it is hard to criticise but a few points where our opinions differ. I hate Vanilla Sky and King Kong, probably because they are week remakes of films I love! Constantine is okay but how did it find itself ahead of the brilliant Children of Men. The Bourne Identity was excellent but where are its equally as great sequels? Avatar was average at best and will fade in time. The Lord Of The Rings Trilogy was brilliant but number one? Not for me! There are a few great comic book movies on the list but not X-Men 2, surly you can find the space for that. A few of my top ten that didn’t make your top 50; City of God, Million Dollar Baby, Battle Royale and the aforementioned Mulholland Drive. All of this can be forgiven for finding space for Serenity, the only movie of the last ten years to make it onto my Top Ten Post Star Wars Sci-Fi Movies list.

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      A lot of people didn’t enjoy Vanilla Sky so I’m not too surprised on that, but I loved Jacksons King Kong. It was an incredible remake, and I’m a fan of both of the other interpretations.

      Still haven’t seen City Of God or Mulholland Drive, but each are on my 100 movies to watch next year. :)

      Reply
  5. Jim says:

    Love the list Heather! Did you make me a cool signature for my posts? If not would you?

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      Done and Done!

      Reply
  6. Cello says:

    I loved Vanilla Sky glad its on there. Where is Blow? Johnny Depps best film IMO. Oh well, my fav movie of all time is at #6 so I can’t complain :) Great list Heather.

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      Blow is good, very good, but not my Top Fifty, 100 maybe.

      I would however like to add District 9, Collateral, and Hot Fuzz somewhere in the list, but I’m not quite sure what I’d replace where, but each of those flicks belong in the fifty.

      Reply
  7. Robert Denner says:

    Heather, this list is very well thought out, and I believe that many of these films definitely belong here, albeit slightly out of order in my opinion. I’m glad you were wise enough to include Oldboy, Pans Labyrinth, and Donnie Darko on this list; and that by the same token, you excluded the garbage of the Star Wars Prequels, and Mel Gibsons over-zealous Passion of the Christ.

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      I actually like the Star Wars prequels but you are right, they don’t have any business on this list. Thanks for your thoughts Rob.

      Reply
  8. As always, Heather, your list is eccentric and painstakingly done. Excellent job!

    “The Departed” certainly deserves the high spot you gave it, as does “Serenity,” a fitting and very witty end to “Firefly.” “Requiem” should most certainly be in any top 10 list, and it made my top 20 all-time favorite films.

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      You’ve inspired me to do a top 100 movies. It’s going to hurt, but I’m going to make it!

      Reply
  9. Katie says:

    Great list, think I’ve seen about half of them but there’s loads on there I want to see!
    Don’t agree with you on all of them, for example I’ve already got into loads of trouble for trashing eternal sunshine and lost in translation, but I’m not surprisd to see them on the list!

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      Eternal Sunshine is widely loved so that surprises me, but LIT not so much. A lot of people haven’t found love for it.

      Reply
  10. Daniel says:

    WOW ! Now THAT is what I call a LIST.

    …I love the picture of Clint Eastwood !!!

    Glad to see “Pitch Black” included. It
    is indeed a taught little sci-fi thriller…
    Way too underrated.

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      Clint Eastwood is just badass.

      Thanks for giving Pitch Black props. It doesn’t often get the love it deserves. I haven’t seen such an innovative Sci-Fi flick till D9. I always appreciate originality.

      Reply
  11. Vanessa says:

    Great list! It does have some interesting choices in it. Serenity scored surprisingly high. I really like the Firefly series but wouldn’t put Serenity in the top 10. I also don’t think 300 would show up anywhere on my list. Glad to see Lost in Translation though!

    Reply
  12. Caz says:

    Fantastic list, containing not only some of my favorite films but also a lot of films which are in my list of best 50 films of the decade.

    Lord of the Rings is such an important trilogy for me personal, because if it wasn’t for The Fellowship of the Ring I would not have totally gotten into films and appreciating them. So I owe that film a lot of praise it is possibly my most watched film. Reading this has inspired me to watch LOTR again extended editions all the way.

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      Thank you! LOTR is such an inspirational film and story. It’s one of those rare movies that make me love the movies more everytime I watch any of the tales. And to think my husband (boyfriend at the time) had to DRAG me to see the Fellowship. I was against because I hated Liv Tyler and didn’t love Viggo. Needless to say, they had me at hello and Viggo is probably my favorite actor right now.

      Reply
  13. PUKHRAJ JANGID says:

    yeh bahut hi behtarin prayash hain, taki koi bhi pichle 10 saalo ki best films chaant sakein. bhid se bahut hi alag, isme kuch file chootl hain, kekin koi bhi pyash pehla aur antim bhi nahi hota, so dhanyawad….

    Reply
  14. Lady Mew says:

    Some of my favs are in here. Good list!

    Eternal Sunshine is a DVD I love to revisit along with Lost in Translation and Pan’s Labyrinth. No wonder I love you so much, Ms Ninja.

    Xoxo,

    Lady Mew

    Reply
    • Jim says:

      As bad as this sounds, I could not for the life of me get into Eternal Sunshine and stopped watching it midway through. I hardly EVER do that. I need to maybe revisit it and see if it was just my frame of mind at the time.

      Reply
  15. Marshall says:

    “The Dark Knight” at number 21?! I think it’s criminal to have it that low … that movie is one of very few released in the past decade that I still watch carefully to see what else I can gain from it.

    And while I wholeheartedly admire “Avatar” for returning the urgency of the theatrical experience, I have a hard time saying that it was the second best movie of the last ten years.

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      I’m proudly sitting here in my Avatar t-shirt. I’m just not going to budge on it! Ha!

      As for Dark Knight. It was initially #35 and then I rewatched it because I hadn’t in awhile and saw that upon repeat viewings it actually got better, but in the scheme of things was not a better film than those I ranked before it. Excellent film though.

      Reply
      • Marshall says:

        Glad to see you have “The Departed” up so high! I absolutely love that movie!

        Reply
        • Heather says:

          Everything about it is great and it’s showing the capacity to live up to its greatness in repeat viewings as well.

          Reply
  16. Parker says:

    Holy shit, at first I thought your list was pretty alright….then, I saw Avatar, hahahahahahahahahah, at number 2, hahahahahaha, must be a mistake, considering its one of the worst movies I’ve seen in a long time….then I saw Serenity, number 6, hahahahahaha, there’s some great acting…….I’m done wasting my time here….Grow the fuck up and watch some good shit. R-tard!!!

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      Are you serious?

      Probably not. Have fun trolling the web!!!!!!!!! Sorry movie fan lists upset you so greatly?

      Reply
  17. john says:

    This list is horrible,what are you retarded? I’m not even gonna begin on the piece of shit movies you chose but I can’t believe the ones you left out like No Country For Old Men was by far the best movie of the decade. Also the lord of the rings trilogy is three films but somehow all three are number 1. Moron! I’m glad to see I’m not the only one who thinks this list is pure shit.

    Serenity? Really, really?
    In the top 10, you must have lost a bet or something and were forced to put that in there. So Heather, are you like rain man retarded. Can count cards but can’t cook toast. Or in your case can work for a movie website but can’t tell what a good movie is. Oh and by the way you forgot to put Gigli in your top ten,ya stupid.

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      Thanks for your input. I’m sure I’ll quit writing about movies from now on because of your comment! Thank you so much!

      Reply
  18. Kaiji says:

    Are you a fucking kid?

    Reply
  19. Grrrr…. you don’t agree with my values! You are wrong! And not only are you wrong, but you suck at life and your entire value system is incorrect. Because you enjoyed a movie that I didn’t, you should be banned from life!

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      We can have an epic showdown to settle this, but I fear your wrestling skills may have me at a disadvantage. Perhaps I’ll bring a gun to the knife fight.

      Reply
  20. I really, really wanted to like “Vanilla Sky,” but after two viewings I haven’t managed to accomplish this goal. I think my general distaste for Tom Cruise is holding me back.

    Reply
  21. Blitzy says:

    I would never be able to put a list together of my favorite movies. I’ve seen most of the action ones, and Black Hawk Down is one I want to see, including Iron Man(1 and 2, when out) and Batman Begins(saw Dark Knight). Gladiator, 300, and yea were good movies.

    But what I really love is the trilogy of Lord of the Rings. That’s like the best series out there! I just watched the Two Towers today, and tomorrow I’m gonna watch Fellowship and Return of the King. I can’t pick a favorite, they’re all just so good. And great idea about keeping them together because they are just a contimuim of each other.

    Reply
  22. brett w says:

    did you even see 25th hour?

    Reply
  23. Peter says:

    I just got to reading this list….Since you have “Zack and Miri” maybe you’ll know why I included “The Amateurs” on my recent comedies list. It is interesting as after reading the films here I have a very good sense of your taste in films. It is too bad we cannot debate in person because I would have to do so to go nuts on your #3, #4 and #5 here….On my own list I have “Almost Famous” at number one and only did my top 10 of the decade. Kudos to you for going so indepth with it. Nicely done. A very eclectic list, even if it does have Donnie Darko on it

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      A lot of people have distaste for Donnie Darko. I get it. It’s certainly an eccentric film, but more than anything I fell in love with the mood. It captured the twisted isolated silence of my youth.

      Reply
  24. dude says:

    I like your list and agree for the most part.
    Probably 30 movies from your list are in my list too.
    I miss City of God, The Pianist,Slumdog Millionaire,No Country for Old Men and Sin City.
    City of God and the Pianist are in my Top5 and i reckon you haven’t seen one of them.
    Harry Potter,Spirited away and 28Days later are defintely not in my Top 50, but whatever.
    My secret love is Harold and Kumar go to White Castle.

    Reply
    • Heather says:

      Harold and Kumar! Ha! We all need our guilty pleasures.

      Slumdog Millionaire I hadn’t seen before, nor The Hurt Locker or they would have made the list, along with The Prestige. Sin City nearly made the cut. :)

      Reply
  25. says:

    These are great articles. Keep up the good work.

    Reply
  26. Dan says:

    Better late than never I’m working on my Top 50 of the decade! Heather, your list definitely gives me some food for thought. I’ve already made up the 50 but there is still room for some movement of placings. I’ve split the LOTR films and…I’ll let you into a little secret…The Two Towers doesn’t make the top 50!

    Although my list is a little different to yours, many of your choices are films that I’ve enjoyed throughout the last ten years. Bit surprised how highly you placed Avatar – you must have really loved that movie! I enjoyed it but I’d like to give it a couple of years to see if it still stands up to multiple viewing.

    Reply
  27. TDK shoulda been MINIMUM 6 spots higher!
    Kai B. Parker recently posted..THE HAPPY 101 AWARD

    Reply
  28. Jack says:

    The author’s praise for Inglorious Bastards is just one example of his bias in films. For that film was nothing more than a fanciful bit of midiocrity, which some might have found fun. In any event, it was certainly no masterpiece as the author asserts.

    Reply
  29. Bill Jones says:

    Love the list! The only thing I would change is replace Avatar with D-9, and maybe move it back a space or two. There are some amazing movies on here though! I’m glad to see someone finally giving credit to movies like Pitch Black and Hero. Check out me and my friends movie rating blog “cazrevilo Teen Reviews @ blogger”! Tell us what you think!

    Reply
  30. honda says:

    i realy loved gladiator and piartes of the caribean

    Reply